"It's an extremely unorthodox sit-down, because most of the guys have hooked up with his fiancee. Awkward!" says The Situation in a preview from Jersey Shore's Dec. 6 episode. During the emotional scene, Sitch's costars pepper LaValle with questions about his intentions with Snooki, then pregnant with their son Lorenzo.
"If I thought of her [as viewers saw her on Jersey Shore], I wouldn't be here. I'm not a jerk-off -- I'm a nice guy," LaValle admits. "Last year, everyone said 'All the [Jersey Shore] guys are talking about you, you're losing her. That's what I want to clear up. If that was ever the case, why would I care about the whole Italy thing? It killed me," he continued, referring to the cast's 2011 summer in Italy filming Jersey Shore's fourth season. In Italy, The Situation admitted that he "kind of had sex" with Snooki, a claim she vehemently denied.