Payne and dancer Peazer, 24, were photographed holding hands with big smiles on their faces later that same evening. Payne dressed all in black, while Peazer wore white jeans and a black and white top.
The twosome enjoyed a holiday date night in the Big Apple with One Direction members Louis Tomlinson, Zayn Malik and their girlfriends, a source tells Us Weekly. The guys treated their ladies to a performance of ELF on Broadway at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre.
During intermission "they were sharing Pringles and Skittles with their girlfriends," an eyewitness tells Us.