Happily ever after wasn't in the cards for Katie and Chris. Shortly after their breakup in 2005, Chris, 33, was arrested for a DUI. After a second offense in 2010, the actor checked into rehab for alcoholism. Lately, Chris leads a much more quiet and healthy lifestyle, having been sober for a year-and-a-half. "Today I'm the luckiest guy alive," he recently told People. And with the upcoming release of "American Reunion," it seems like this might be the second chance he deserves.