In 1993, the Olympic tennis player was cited for allegedly lifting a $15 ring from a shopping mall in Tampa, Fla. Jennifer maintained she simply forgot to return the ring after trying several ones on at a jewelry kiosk. "Everywhere we go in the world, she's always collecting rings, and this time she just forgot to give the ring back and they called the police," Jennifer's father, Stefano Capriati, told the New York Times following the incident. "Jennifer is very sorry that it happened. … I can't punish her for it; she didn't mean to do it." We have to wonder: Is this where Lindsay Lohan learned her "absentmindedness" defense?