Simon isn't the only person from "American Idol" that Paula's been allegedly linked to. In May 2005, "Primetime Live" reported claims by Season 2 contestant Corey Clark (top left) that he and Paula had an affair and that she privately coached him on how to win the competition during his tenure on the show in 2003. Paula denied all of the singer's accusations. (Corey ended up being disqualified after making it to the top 12, when his arrest record came to light.) However, after investigating the matter, Fox found "insufficient evidence that the communications between Mr. Clark and Ms. Abdul in any way aided his performance."